Tuesday, September 12, 2006
When you listen to The State on education, it's like hearing a foreign country's Minister of Propaganda. There was no accident at Chernobyl . . . there is no AIDS in South Africa . . . there's almost nothing wrong with South Carolina government-run schools. Wait, what's that last one? That can't be right.Today's editorial from The State continues an unending campaign to pretend that children are being adequately served South Carolina's schools. The only problem is that the State Department of Education disagrees with The State.According to the State Department of Education.Over 70% of South Carolina public school 8th graders can't read and write at proficient level
Over 76% of South Carolina public school 8th graders can't do math at proficient level
Over 76% of South Carolina public school 8th graders can't do science at proficient level
Over 75% of South Carolina public school 8th graders can't do social studies at proficient level
I think those statistics are pretty grim but The State insists things are fine; after all, we're "on track to reach the national average within eight years on all significant measures of achievement."First of all, why is this an excuse? Eight years? If I have a son in the 6th grade, our schools will be up to mediocre in eight years? By the time he's 20, the middle schools will be up to 'mediocre,' if I believe the line of the politicians, known for their honesty and efficacy. Seriously, even if we believe the politicians, why is it okay to condemn the hundreds of thousands of children in public schools today, to a substandard education? (Answer: Because Brad Warthen's kids aren' t there.)
Second, it's simply not the case that you can extrapolate our improvements along a decade-long timescale.
Third, even if the public schools were improving at the glacier-like pace that editor Warthen breathlessly insists, why is it okay to deny unsatisfied taxpayers the chance to control their own child's education?
Fourth, what about the dismal graduation rate? Even The State admits that ours is horrible. It hovers around 50% (51% according to the left-wing Urban Institute; 49% according to the centrist United Health Foundation; 53% according to the conservative Manhattan Institute). Since high school graduates typically earn about 50% more per year than drop-outs, this is a pretty big deal.
No amount of failure will ever convince Brad Warthen and The State that our state's parents deserve more control and our state's children deserve a better deal. It's bad enough to believe that the current morass is fine-and-dandy for the next generation; actively defending the status quo of failure and suffering is despicable.
Posted by Bill Smith at 12:05 PM |
10 comments